Tile vs Shingle Roof
When it comes to roofing materials, tile and shingle are two of the most popular options. But which one is better for your home? In this article, we will compare tile vs shingle roofing material so that you can make an informed decision.
Pros And Cons Of Tile Roofs
Tile roofs are known for their durability and lifespan. They can last up to 75 years, compared to shingle roofs which typically last around 25 to 50 years if you’re lucky. Tile roofs are also fire-resistant, which is a major plus. They provide a greater benefit in regards to being energy efficient. Which is great to have in this Florida weather.
The wind resistance of a tile roof can reach up to 180 mph, significantly more than a shingle. So between the wind, durability, longevity and appearance, they out perform a shingle roof every day.
However, they are also more expensive than shingle roofs. The material and labor bring the price up significantly. Tile is a slightly more labor intensive and can require amore qualified skill set to install. So not every roofer is able to perform this type of roof replacement.
Tile roofs can be a beautiful addition to any home, but they come with some drawbacks. One of the biggest is that they can be very fragile in their old age. If someone walks on a tile roof to repair it, clean it or hang Christmas lights, they can easily break. This is why it’s important to be very careful when walking on tile roofs, especially if they are older.
Pros And Cons Of Shingle Roofs
Shingle roofs are less expensive than tile roofs, and they are more popular, so they are easier to find a contractor to install them. Some other benefits of shingle roofs include: Easier to repair than tile roofs and less expensive for an individual leak repair. They come in a wide variety of colors and styles to match your home.
A shingle roof can have a life span anywhere from 25 to 50 years depending on the shingle. The warranties that state “limited lifetime” are misleading. Also, how long a roof lasts on paper and in reality are two different things.
With shingle roofing, you can expect a wind resistance of up to 130 mph depending on the shingle. Not every architectural shingle is made the same, so be sure to read the fine print of your warranty.
However, they are not as durable as tile roofs and do not last as long. They are also not as fire-resistant as tile roofs. Most shingles are highly susceptible to hail damage. There are some hail resistance shingle options, so be sure to ask our roof estimator when he meets you to provide a quote.
Which Roof Is Better For Your Home?
When it comes to tile vs shingle roofing, both have their pros and cons. It really depends on your budget and your needs as to which one is better for you. If you need a durable roof that will last for decades, tile is the way to go. If you’re looking for a less expensive roof that is still stylish, then shingle might be your choice.
The value of your house will certainly go up if you install a tile roof. Not only is the curb appeal something to mention but it will be an overall investment into your home. If you’re planning on only living in your home for a short time, you could benefit from the shingle roof since it’s less expensive.
As far as over all performance, the tile roof out performs a shingle roof in wind resistance, withstanding hail or falling branches, it can also provide a more energy efficient covering to your home.
When choosing between your options of a tile vs shingle roof, it helps to have physical roofing material in your hand to hold up to you home or even lay on the roof to get a feel for the appearance. This comes in handy especially when choosing roof tile colors.
If you’re unsure of which roofing material to choose, contact our team at Blue Dog Roofing & Contracting. We will be happy to meet with you, inspect your roof and help you choose the best roofing material for your home. Schedule a free roof inspection today!
Warranty On Tile vs Shingle Roof
You will often receive a warranty from your roofer but also from the manufacturer. It’s important to read and understand the fine print. For example, there are shingle warranties out there that say they last 50 years. But the wind resistance is only covered for 15 years.
Manufactures of these roofing materials will often certify their installers. There will be different levels of certifications and each one will determine what the roofing contractor is able to offer in the warranty. Some warranties are dependent on the method of installation.
Be sure to ask your contractor questions about this when they come to give you a quote for tile vs shingle roofing. Also, be sure to get everything in writing before any work is done on your home.
When it comes to tile vs shingle roofing, tile is the winner in the warranty department. This is because tile roofs are not as susceptible to the elements and last much longer than shingle roofs.
As always, be sure to get a workmanship warranty from your roofing contractor. A typical warranty here in Florida for a tile roof replacement can be anywhere from 5 to 10 years. The same goes for shingle.